Labor Dept. Warns Health Plans Over Inaccurate Provider Directories
A federal survey found 36% of provider directory listings were wrong, leaving workers exposed to surprise out-of-network bills.
The U.S. Department of Labor issued an enforcement alert Tuesday directing employers and health plan fiduciaries to ensure provider directories are accurate and current, after a sweeping government survey uncovered widespread errors that expose workers and retirees to unexpected medical costs.
The department's Employee Benefits Security Administration conducted a secret shopper survey in which agency staff contacted more than 27,000 providers across 27 health networks. The results were stark: 36% of the directory listings checked contained incorrect information. When EBSA applied a broader "pathway to service" standard — measuring whether providers could be reached, confirmed as in-network, and available to see new patients within 30 days — 66% of medical and surgical providers failed to meet all criteria, and 74% of mental health and substance use disorder providers fell short.
Read more Fed Issues Enforcement Action Against Former First Security Bancorp Employee →
Secretary of Labor Keith Sonderling said the guidance puts health plans and insurance issuers on notice that inaccurate directories are unacceptable. Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act and the No Surprises Act, plans are legally required to verify, update, and publish accurate network information on a regular basis. Failure to do so can expose fiduciaries to regulatory scrutiny.
The enforcement alert outlines the statutory obligations plans must meet, highlights key findings from the secret shopper survey, and offers employers a set of questions to put to their service providers about how directories are maintained and updated. Officials said inaccurate listings cause tangible harm — including delays in treatment, higher out-of-pocket expenses, and cases in which patients forgo care entirely after failing to locate an in-network provider.
Employers and workers seeking assistance with private-sector health or retirement plans can reach EBSA at askebsa.dol.gov or by calling 866-444-3272. Continue reading at DOL News Releases and Briefs.